A
debate is ongoing at Twenty-something Journalist over the merits of journalists going to graduate school. Some are pro, some are con.
I fall into the pro category, but it's not simply because I recently finished a grad program myself. I happen to be one of those people who thinks that education for education's sake is always a worthy endeavor.
That aside though, what advice should we give each other about going on to graduate school. The answer is that, it depends.
What are your goals? Going to grad school (or not going) will largely depend on how an advanced degree can help you meet those goals. If an advanced degree won't help you get where you want to be, then maybe your resources (time and money) will be better spent elsewhere.
- Goal: SKIP THE SMALL-MARKET JAIL SENTENCE
Okay, so it's not a jail sentence for everyone, but for me, working in small markets to get the requisite years of experience in journalism was killing me. I'm not a small-town kind of guy. I live in San Diego now, and even *it's* a bit small for my tastes. So will a master's degree let you move up the ladder faster? A few years ago, probably not. But today, the waters are churning in a different direction and journalistic employers are starting to recognize that not having xx number of years doesn't mean a lot. Like other industries, we too, are starting to understand that education (particularly if it comes with an advanced skill set) can substitute for experience and that skill and ability are just as important as on-the-job experience.
- Goal: GET SPECIALIZED TRAINING
This is a yes. There are many journalism graduate programs that specialize in certain areas (like investigative reporting at Point Park University or entrepreneurial skills at The City University of New York) or let you specialize in whatever you want. My program at WVU let me work toward a thesis project that involved three special skill sets, all useful for today's journalist: investigative reporting, online production/development and converged media (video, audio, print, photos). Not all programs do this, though, and some are strictly mass comm research oriented, so be sure and fully investigate the program you're considering. - Goal: GET TRAINED, PERIOD
If you're undergrad wasn't in communications or journalism, it can be difficult to get a job in the field. A grad program in journalism could obviously help -- though many grad programs expect some basic journalism coursework to have already been completed. If you haven't, you'll likely have additional graduation requirements imposed.
- Goal: BE A TEACHER
If you think teaching is in your future, either in a few years or a few decades, then grad school is almost a must. Most universities won't hire professors that don't have master's degrees and in most places you can't be tenure track unless you've gone on to get a PhD, either. The nice part for people like me, who are still relatively young and have some extra time (I freelance, so my schedule is my own), you can make some extra money by becoming an adjunct at a local university. It usually only takes the master's degree (though a few on-the-job years won't hurt).
The decision to go to graduate school for me was a combination of some of the above (I'm also considering law school in about two years, but that's a whole other story) and part of me wishes I'd done it right out of college. But I waited for about three years (I finished undergrad a semester early, in January 2003) so I think the combination of my professional experience plus the master's degree has made me a pretty competitive job candidate.
When should you go? I can't answer that for you, no one can. In this business (as in most, but more so in journalism), years-on-the-job are always very helpful. But again, even that tide has started to turn in news business. Other industries have figured out how to hire and promote based on skill, ability AND experience, we're just figuring that one out. The opportunities for well educated, well trained journalists will get better going forward.
Like I said above, it's going to take a careful weighing of your goals against what a graduate degree can get you. Here's some advice to go away with: Don't listen to the person telling you that graduate school is a waste of your time, and don't listen to the person telling you that you have to go to graduate school (now!). Listen to yourself.
Rivers and Sydney, my dogs